They won the senior championships in 1899-1900, 1900-01, 1901-02, and 1903-03. They unsuccesfully challenged for the Stanley Cup in 1902.
The Welligtons also won the OHA junior championship in 1896-97.
The senior team played in the following seasons:
- 1898-99 OHA Senior Season
- 1900-01 OHA Senior Season
- 1901-02 OHA Senior Season
- 1902-03 OHA Senior Season
The intermediate team played in:
- 1897-98 OHA Intermediate Groups
- 1900-01 OHA Intermediate Groups
- 1901-02 OHA Intermediate Groups
- 1902-03 OHA Intermediate Groups
These were the seasons for the junior team: