List of Division I AHCA All-American Teams

===First Team===

====1950s====
{{col-start}}

{{col-3}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3 | [[1953–54 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1953–54]]
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Jim Mattson]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|-
| [[Spike Schultz]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Ken Yackel]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|- 
| [[Jim Haas (ice hockey)|Jim Haas]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[John Mayasich]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|- 
| [[Richard Dougherty]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|-
| [[Ben Cherski]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[Bill MacFarland]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|}
{{col-3}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1954–55 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1954–55]]
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Lorne Howes]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Chuck Flynn]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Mike Buchanan]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Bob Schiller (ice hockey)|Bob Schiller]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Doug Silverberg]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Phil Hilton]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Bill Cleary (ice hockey)|Bill Cleary]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Dick Dunnigan]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Bill MacFarland]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[John Mayasich]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|- 
| [[Bill Reichart]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Tom Rendall]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Clare Smith]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|}
{{col-3}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1955–56 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1955–56]]
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Lorne Howes]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Bob Schiller (ice hockey)|Bob Schiller]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Doug Silverberg]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Art Smith (ice hockey defenseman)|Art Smith]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Garry Kearns]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|-
| [[Bill MacFarland]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Jack McManus (ice hockey)|Jack McManus]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|- 
| [[Bill Reichart]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Ed Rowe]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|}
{{col-end}}
{{col-start}}

{{col-4}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1956–57 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1956–57]]
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Eddie MacDonald]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Pat Presley]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[Bill Steenson]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Don Wishart]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Bob Cleary]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|-
| [[Bill Hay]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Joe McLean]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|-
| [[Ron O'Brien (ice hockey)|Ron O'Brien]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[Ed Rowe]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|}
{{col-4}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1957–58 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1957–58]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Eddie MacDonald]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Bob Dupuis (ice hockey defenseman)|Bob Dupuis]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Don McLeod (ice hockey defenseman)|Don McLeod]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|-
| [[Bob Cleary]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Bob Marquis (ice hockey)|Bob Marquis]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|-
| [[Paul Midghall]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Jack McCartan]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|- 
| [[Bill Steenson]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Ed Zemrau]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|-
| [[Bill Hay]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Dick Burg]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|-
| [[Bob McCusker]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|-
| [[Bob White(ice hockey)|Bob White]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|}
{{col-4}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1958–59 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1958–59]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Gerry Jones (ice hockey)|Gerry Jones]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Yale Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Yale]]
|- 
| [[Joe Jangro]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Pat Presley]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[Bob Marquis (ice hockey)|Bob Marquis]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|-
| [[Paul Midghall]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|-
| [[Phil Latreille]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Middlebury Panthers|Middlebury]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Joe Selinger]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Bill Steenson]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Bob Watt]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[John Kosiancic]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|- 
| [[Bob White(ice hockey)|Bob White]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Murray Williamson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|}
{{col-4}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1959–60 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1959–60]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Tom Wahman]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Dartmouth Indians men's ice hockey|Dartmouth]]
|- 
| [[Red Martin]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Rusty Ingersoll]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Dartmouth Indians men's ice hockey|Dartmouth]]
|- 
| [[Terry Slater (ice hockey)|Terry Slater]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|-
| [[Phil Latreille]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Middlebury Panthers|Middlebury]]
|-
| [[Art Chisholm]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Northeastern Huskies men's ice hockey|Northeastern]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[George Cuculick]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|- 
| [[Marty Howe (ice hockey b. 1937)|Marty Howe]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|- 
| [[George Konik]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|-
| [[Paul Coppo]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|-
| [[Reg Morelli]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Bill Masterton]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|}
{{col-end}}

====1960s====
{{col-start}}

{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1960–61 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1960–61]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Rod Blackburn]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|- 
| [[Arlie Parker]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[Red Martin]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
| [[Terry Slater (ice hockey)|Terry Slater]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[Phil Latreille]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Middlebury Panthers|Middlebury]]
|-
| [[Art Chisholm]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Northeastern Huskies men's ice hockey|Northeastern]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[George Kirkwood]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|- 
| [[Marty Howe (ice hockey b. 1937)|Marty Howe]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|- 
| [[Grant Munro (ice hockey)|Grant Munro]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|-
| [[Red Berenson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Bill Masterton]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|-
| [[Jerry Walker (ice hockey)|Jerry Walker]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1961–62 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1961–62]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Frank Stephenson (ice hockey)|Frank Stephenson]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Colby Mules|Colby]]
|- 
| [[Dave Johnston (ice hockey)|Dave Johnston]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Arlie Parker]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|-
| [[Bill Hogan]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Ron Ryan]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colby Mules|Colby]]
|-
| [[Dates Fryberger]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Middlebury Panthers|Middlebury]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[John Chandik]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Henry Akervall]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|- 
| [[Elov Seger]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|- 
| [[Lou Angotti]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|-
| [[Red Berenson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Jerry Sullivan (ice hockey)|Jerry Sullivan]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3 | [[1962–63 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1962–63]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Richie Broadbelt]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[Pat Brophy]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Dave Johnston (ice hockey)|Dave Johnston]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Cal Wagner]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|-
| [[Bob Brinkworth]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|- 
| [[Jack Leetch]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
| [[Dates Fryberger]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Middlebury Panthers|Middlebury]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Garry Bauman]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|- 
| [[Lou Nanne]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|- 
| [[Don Ross (ice hockey)|Don Ross]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[George Hill (ice hockey)|George Hill]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|-
| [[Al McLean (ice hockey)|Al McLean]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Dave Merrifield]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[Bill Staub]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3 | [[1963–64 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1963–64]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Bob Perani]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[Richie Green (ice hockey)|Richie Green]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Larry Kish]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Providence Friars men's ice hockey|Providence]]
|- 
| [[Cal Wagner]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Corby Adams]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|-
| [[Bob Brinkworth]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|-
| [[Jerry Knightley]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Garry Bauman]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|- 
| [[Carl Lackey]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Tom Polonic]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Craig Falkman]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|- 
| [[John Simus]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|-
| [[Gordon Wilkie]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1964–65 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1964–65]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Terry Yurkiewicz]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|-
| [[Jack Ferriera]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Bob Gaudreau]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Brown Bears men's ice hockey|Brown]]
|- 
| [[Tom Ross (defenseman)|Tom Ross]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|-
| [[John Cunniff]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Grant Heffernan]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Providence Friars men's ice hockey|Providence]]
|-
| [[Jerry Knightley]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Tony Esposito]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|- 
| [[Don Ross (ice hockey)|Don Ross]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Wayne Smith (ice hockey)|Wayne Smith]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|-
| [[Doug Roberts (ice hockey)|Doug Roberts]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Mel Wakabayashi]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Doug Woog]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|}
{{col-end}}
{{col-start}}

{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1965–66 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1965–66]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Terry Yurkiewicz]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Bob Gaudreau]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Brown Bears men's ice hockey|Brown]]
|- 
| [[Tom Ross (defenseman)|Tom Ross]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Fred Bassi]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|-
| [[John Cunniff]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
| [[Doug Ferguson (ice hockey)|Doug Ferguson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Tony Esposito]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|- 
| [[Bob Hill (ice hockey)|Bob Hill]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|- 
| [[Bruce Riutta]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|- 
| [[Wayne Smith (ice hockey)|Wayne Smith]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|- 
| [[Terry Casey (ice hockey)|Terry Casey]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[Bob Lindberg]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|-
| [[Doug Volmar]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1966–67 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1966–67]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Ken Dryden]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Brian Gilmour (ice hockey)|Brian Gilmour]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Harry Orr]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Doug Ferguson (ice hockey)|Doug Ferguson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|-
| [[John Morrison (ice hockey b. 1945)|John Morrison]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Yale Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Yale]]
|-
| [[Jerry York]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Tony Esposito]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|-
| [[Rick Best]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|- 
| [[Jerry Lafond]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Bruce Riutta]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|-
| [[Keith Christiansen]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|-
| [[Bob Lindberg]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Gary Milroy]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|-
| [[Jim Wiste]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1967–68 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1967–68]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Ken Dryden]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Bruce Pattison]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Walt Stanowski]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Brian Cornell]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|-
| [[Wayne Small]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Brown Bears men's ice hockey|Brown]]
|-
| [[Herb Wakabayashi]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[James Keough]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Terry Abram]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Keith Magnuson]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|-
| [[Gary Gambucci]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|-
| [[Bob Munro]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Jim Wiste]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1968–69 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1968–69]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Ken Dryden]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Paul Hurley]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Bruce Pattison]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Joe Cavanagh]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Brian Cornell]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Timothy Sheehy (ice hockey)|Tim Sheehy]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
| [[Peter Tufford]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|-
| [[Herb Wakabayashi]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Rick Duffett]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Keith Magnuson]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|- 
| [[John Marks (ice hockey)|John Marks]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[Bob Collyard]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|-
| [[Al Karlander]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|-
| [[George Morrison (ice hockey forward)|George Morrison]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|- 
| [[Bob Munro]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1969–70 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1969–70]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Bruce Bullock]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Dan Lodboa]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Mike Hyndman]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Curt Bennett]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Brown Bears men's ice hockey|Brown]]
|- 
| [[Joe Cavanagh]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Tom Earl]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colgate Red Raiders men's ice hockey|Colgate]]
|- 
| [[Timothy Sheehy (ice hockey)|Tim Sheehy]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Murray McLachlan (ice hockey)|Murray McLachlan]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|- 
| [[Ron Busniuk]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|- 
| [[John Jagger (ice hockey)|John Jagger]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[John Marks (ice hockey)|John Marks]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Wally Olds]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|-
| [[Bob Collyard]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Murray Keogan]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|-
| [[George Morrison (ice hockey forward)|George Morrison]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|}
{{col-end}}

====1970s====
{{col-start}}

{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1970–71 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1970–71]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Bruce Bullock]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Bob Brown (ice hockey)|Bob Brown]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Steve Warr (ice hockey)|Steve Warr]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Joe Cavanagh]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Kevin Pettit]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Steve Stirling]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Morris Trewin]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|- 
| [[Mike Christie (ice hockey)|Mike Christie]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|- 
| [[Rob Murray (ice hockey defenseman)|Rob Murray]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|-
| [[Walt Ledingham]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|- 
| [[Don Thompson (ice hockey)|Don Thompson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|-
| [[Vic Venasky]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1971–72 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1971–72]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Dan Brady (ice hockey)|Dan Brady]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Bob Brown (ice hockey)|Bob Brown]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Steve Warr (ice hockey)|Steve Warr]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[John Danby (ice hockey)|John Danby]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Larry Fullan]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[David Hynes (ice hockey)|David Hynes]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Jim Watt (ice hockey)|Jim Watt]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Jeff Rotsch]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Alan Hangsleben]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[Bob Winograd]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|-
| [[Walt Ledingham]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|- 
| [[Doug Palazzari]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|-
| [[Tom Peluso]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1972–73 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1972–73]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Ed Walsh (ice hockey)|Ed Walsh]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Tom Mellor]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Keith Smith (ice hockey)|Keith Smith]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Brown Bears men's ice hockey|Brown]]
|- 
| [[Gordon Clark (ice hockey)|Gordon Clark]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|- 
| [[Steve Dolloff]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Bob McManama]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Ron Grahame]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|- 
| [[Bob Boyd (ice hockey)|Bob Boyd]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Bill Nyrop]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Notre Dame Fighting Irish men's ice hockey|Notre Dame]]
|-
| [[Pat Boutette]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|- 
| [[Eddie Bumbacco]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Notre Dame Fighting Irish men's ice hockey|Notre Dame]]
|-
| [[Rob Palmer (ice hockey, born 1952)|Rob Palmer]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3 | [[1973–74 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1973–74]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Cap Raeder]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|- 
| [[George Kuzmicz]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Vic Stanfield]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Bill Burlington]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Gordon Clark (ice hockey)|Gordon Clark]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|-
| [[Randy Roth (ice hockey)|Randy Roth]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Robbie Moore]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Norm Barnes]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Jim Nahrgang]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|- 
| [[Steve Colp]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|-
| [[Doug Palazzari]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|-
| [[Mike Zuke]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1974–75 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1974–75]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Brian Petrovek]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Vic Stanfield]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Ron Wilson (ice hockey b. 1955)|Ron Wilson]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Providence Friars men's ice hockey|Providence]]
|- 
| [[Rick Meagher]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Tim O'Connell]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Vermont Catamounts men's ice hockey|Vermont]]
|-
| [[Randy Roth (ice hockey)|Randy Roth]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Eddie Mio]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|-
| [[Les Auge]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|- 
| [[Brian Engblom]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Bob D'Alvise]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|-
| [[Mike Polich]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|-
| [[Tom Ross (ice hockey)|Tom Ross]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|}
{{col-end}}
{{col-start}}

{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1975–76 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1975–76]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Brian Shields]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Peter Brown (ice hockey)|Peter Brown]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Ron Wilson (ice hockey b. 1955)|Ron Wilson]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Providence Friars men's ice hockey|Providence]]
|- 
| [[Cliff Cox]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|- 
| [[Jamie Hislop]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|- 
| [[Rick Meagher]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|-
| [[Bill Gilligan]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Brown Bears men's ice hockey|Brown]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Eddie Mio]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Jack Brownschidle]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Notre Dame Fighting Irish men's ice hockey|Notre Dame]]
|- 
| [[Craig Norwich]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|-
| [[Tom Ross (ice hockey)|Tom Ross]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Mike Eaves]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|-
| [[Mike Zuke]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1976–77 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1976–77]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Brian Shields]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Bill Blackwood]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Tim Burke (ice hockey)|Tim Burke]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|- 
| [[Rick Meagher]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Bob Miller (ice hockey)|Bob Miller]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|- 
| [[Dave Taylor (ice hockey)|Dave Taylor]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Julian Baretta]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Jack Brownschidle]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Notre Dame Fighting Irish men's ice hockey|Notre Dame]]
|- 
| [[Craig Norwich]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|-
| [[Dave Debol]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Mike Eaves]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|-
| [[Brian Walsh (ice hockey)|Brian Walsh]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Notre Dame Fighting Irish men's ice hockey|Notre Dame]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1977–78 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1977–78]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Mike Laycock]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Brown Bears men's ice hockey|Brown]]
|- 
| [[Bill Blackwood]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Peter Shier]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|-
| [[Ralph Cox]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|- 
| [[Joe Mullen]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Lance Nethery]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Ernie Glanville]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|- 
| [[Curt Giles]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|- 
| [[Ken Morrow]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]]
|-
| [[Doug Berry (ice hockey)|Doug Berry]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|-
| [[Mike Eaves]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Mark Johnson (ice hockey)|Mark Johnson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1978–79 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1978–79]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Jim Craig (ice hockey)|Jim Craig]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Louis Cote (ice hockey)|Louis Cote]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Vermont Catamounts men's ice hockey|Vermont]]
|- 
| [[Jack O'Callahan]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|-
| [[Ralph Cox]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|- 
| [[Joe Mullen]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Lance Nethery]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Bob Iwabuchi]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Bill Baker (ice hockey)|Bill Baker]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|- 
| [[Curt Giles]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|- 
| [[Mark Johnson (ice hockey)|Mark Johnson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|-
| [[Kevin Maxwell (ice hockey)|Kevin Maxwell]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[Mark Pavelich]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1979–80 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1979–80]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Mark Holden (ice hockey)|Mark Holden]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Brown Bears men's ice hockey|Brown]]
|- 
| [[Andre Aubut]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|- 
| [[Louis Cote (ice hockey)|Louis Cote]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Vermont Catamounts men's ice hockey|Vermont]]
|-
| [[Bill Army]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Ross Brownridge]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Dartmouth Big Green men's ice hockey|Dartmouth]]
|- 
| [[Craig Homola]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Vermont Catamounts men's ice hockey|Vermont]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Roy Schultz]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Dave Feamster]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Howard Walker]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Theran Welsh]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Murray Eaves]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Tim Harrer]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|-
| [[Greg Meredith]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Notre Dame Fighting Irish men's ice hockey|Notre Dame]]
|- 
| [[Mark Taylor (ice hockey)|Mark Taylor]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|}
{{col-end}}

====1980s====
{{col-start}}

{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1980–81 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1980–81]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Don Sylvestri]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Mark Fusco]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Ed Small]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|-
| [[Sandy Beadle]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Northeastern Huskies men's ice hockey|Northeastern]]
|-
| [[Bryan Cleaver]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Gary Conn]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Paul Fricker]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Marc Chorney]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Tim Watters]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|-
| [[Steve Bozek]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Northern Michigan Wildcats men's ice hockey|Northern Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Neal Broten]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|-
| [[Aaron Broten]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1981–82 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1981–82]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Brian Hayward]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Mark Fusco]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Chris Renaud (ice hockey)|Chris Renaud]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Colgate Red Raiders men's ice hockey|Colgate]]
|-
| [[Andy Brickley]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|-
| [[Steve Cruikshank]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Kirk McCaskill]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Vermont Catamounts men's ice hockey|Vermont]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Ron Scott]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Bruce Driver]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Brian MacLellan]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]]
|- 
| [[Brian Hills]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]]
|-
| [[George McPhee]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]]
|-
| [[John Newberry (ice hockey)|John Newberry]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1982–83 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1982–83]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Darren Eliot]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Gray Weicker]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[Mark Fusco]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Randy Velischek]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Providence Friars men's ice hockey|Providence]]
|-
| [[Bob Brooke]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Yale Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Yale]]
|-
| [[Kurt Kleinendorst]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Providence Friars men's ice hockey|Providence]]
|-
| [[Colin Patterson (ice hockey)|Colin Patterson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Ron Scott]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Doug Lidster]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[James Patrick (ice hockey)|James Patrick]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[Kirt Bjork]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Notre Dame Fighting Irish men's ice hockey|Notre Dame]]
|- 
| [[Patrick Flatley]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|-
| [[Brian Hills]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1983–84 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1983–84]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Cleon Daskalakis]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Bob Armstring]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Dave Fretz]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[John Carter (ice hockey)|John Carter]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|-
| [[Adam Oates]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|-
| [[Steve Smith (ice hockey forward)|Steve Smith]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colgate Red Raiders men's ice hockey|Colgate]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Jon Casey]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Garry Galley]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]]
|- 
| [[Tom Kurvers]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|-
| [[Dan Kane]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]]
|- 
| [[Paul Pooley]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Ohio State Buckeyes men's ice hockey|Ohio State]]
|-
| [[Bill Watson (ice hockey)|Bill Watson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1984–85 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1984–85]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Chris Terreri]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Providence Friars men's ice hockey|Providence]]
|- 
| [[Dave Fretz]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Ken Hammond (ice hockey)|Ken Hammond]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|- 
| [[Tim Army]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Providence Friars men's ice hockey|Providence]]
|-
| [[Scott Fusco]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|-
| [[Adam Oates]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Rick Kosti]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|- 
| [[Norm Maciver]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|- 
| [[Dan McFall]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|-
| [[Pat Micheletti]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|-
| [[Kelly Miller (ice hockey b. 1963)|Kelly Miller]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Craig Simpson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|-
| [[Bill Watson (ice hockey)|Bill Watson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{{col-end}}
{{col-start}}

{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1985–86 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1985–86]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Doug Dadswell]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Cliff Abrecht]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Princeton Tigers men's ice hockey|Princeton]]
|- 
| [[Mike Dark]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|- 
| [[Scott Fusco]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|-
| [[Scott Harlow]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
| [[Joe Nieuwendyk]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Gary Kruzich]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]]
|- 
| [[Wayne Gagné]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Western Michigan Broncos men's ice hockey|Western Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Norm Maciver]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|-
| [[Dallas Gaume]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|- 
| [[Mike Donnelly]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|-
| [[Dan Dorion]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Western Michigan Broncos men's ice hockey|Western Michigan]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1986–87 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1986–87]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Bruce Racine]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Northeastern Huskies men's ice hockey|Northeastern]]
|- 
| [[Mark Benning]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Brian Leetch]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Craig Janney]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
| [[Lane MacDonald]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|-
| [[Joe Nieuwendyk]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Gary Kruzich]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]]
|- 
| [[Wayne Gagné]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Western Michigan Broncos men's ice hockey|Western Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Ian Kidd]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[Tony Hrkac]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Bob Joyce]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[Mitch Messier]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1987–88 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1987–88]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Bruce Racine]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Northeastern Huskies men's ice hockey|Northeastern]]
|- 
| [[Jack Capuano]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|- 
| [[Brian McColgan]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[Rejean Boivin]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colgate Red Raiders men's ice hockey|Colgate]]
|- 
| [[David Capuano]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|-
| [[Pete Lappin]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Robb Stauber]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|- 
| [[Scott Paluch]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]]
|- 
| [[Paul Stanton]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|-
| [[Steve Johnson (ice hockey)|Steve Johnson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Paul Ranheim]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|-
| [[Mark Vermette]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Lake Superior State Lakers men's ice hockey|Lake Superior State]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1988–89 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1988–89]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Mike O'Neill (ice hockey)|Mike O'Neill]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Yale Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Yale]]
|- 
| [[Greg Brown (ice hockey)|Greg Brown]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Mike Hurlbut]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[David Capuano]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|- 
| [[Lane MacDonald]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Kyle McDonough]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Vermont Catamounts men's ice hockey|Vermont]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Bruce Hoffort]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Lake Superior State Lakers men's ice hockey|Lake Superior State]]
|- 
| [[Kord Cernich]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Lake Superior State Lakers men's ice hockey|Lake Superior State]]
|- 
| [[Myles O'Connor]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Kip Miller]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Greg Parks]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]]
|- 
| [[Bobby Reynolds (ice hockey)|Bobby Reynolds]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1989–90 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1989–90]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Dave Gagnon]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Colgate Red Raiders men's ice hockey|Colgate]]
|- 
| [[Greg Brown (ice hockey)|Greg Brown]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Rob Cowie]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Northeastern Huskies men's ice hockey|Northeastern]]
|- 
| [[David Emma]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Steve Heinze]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Joé Juneau]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Chad Erickson]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|- 
| [[Rob Blake]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]]
|- 
| [[Russ Parent]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Nelson Emerson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]]
|-
| [[Kip Miller]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|-
| [[Gary Shuchuk]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|}
{{col-end}}

====1990s====
{{col-start}}

{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1990–91 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1990–91]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Les Kuntar]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[Keith Carney]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|- 
| [[Dan Ratushny]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[David Emma]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Shawn McEachern]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|-
| [[Jean-Yves Roy (ice hockey)|Jean-Yves Roy]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Darrin Madeley]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Lake Superior State Lakers men's ice hockey|Lake Superior State]]
|- 
| [[Brad Werenka]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Northern Michigan Wildcats men's ice hockey|Northern Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Jason Woolley]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|-
| [[Scott Beattie]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Northern Michigan Wildcats men's ice hockey|Northern Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Jim Dowd (ice hockey)|Jim Dowd]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Lake Superior State Lakers men's ice hockey|Lake Superior State]]
|-
| [[Greg Johnson (ice hockey)|Greg Johnson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1991–92 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1991–92]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Parris Duffus]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Mike Brewer (ice hockey)|Mike Brewer]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Brown Bears men's ice hockey|Brown]]
|- 
| [[Daniel Laperrière]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[Scott Pellerin]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|-
| [[David Sacco]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|-
| [[Jean-Yves Roy (ice hockey)|Jean-Yves Roy]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Darrin Madeley]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Lake Superior State Lakers men's ice hockey|Lake Superior State]]
|- 
| [[Mark Astley]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Lake Superior State Lakers men's ice hockey|Lake Superior State]]
|- 
| [[Joby Messier]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|-
| [[Dallas Drake]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Northern Michigan Wildcats men's ice hockey|Northern Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Denny Felsner]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Dwayne Norris]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1992–93 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1992–93]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Mike Dunham]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|- 
| [[Chris Imes]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|- 
| [[Jack Duffy (ice hockey)|Jack Duffy]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Yale Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Yale]]
|- 
| [[David Sacco]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|-
| [[Ted Drury]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|-
| [[Paul Kariya]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Jamie Ram]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|- 
| [[Barry Richter]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Brett Hauer]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|-
| [[Bryan Smolinski]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|-
| [[Derek Plante]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|- 
| [[Greg Johnson (ice hockey)|Greg Johnson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1993–94 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1993–94]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Dwayne Roloson]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[UMass-Lowell River Hawks men's ice hockey|Massachusetts-Lowell]]
|- 
| [[Brian Mueller]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Sean McCann (ice hockey)|Sean McCann]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Mike Pomichter]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Craig Conroy]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|-
| [[Steve Martins]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Jamie Ram]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]]
|- 
| [[Shawn Reid]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[John Gruden]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Ferris State Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Ferris State]]
|-
| [[David Oliver (ice hockey)|David Oliver]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Brian Wiseman]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Chris Marinucci]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1994–95 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1994–95]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Blair Allison]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|- 
| [[Brian Mueller]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Chris Imes]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|- 
| [[Mike Grier]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Greg Bullock]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[UMass-Lowell River Hawks men's ice hockey|Massachusetts-Lowell]]
|- 
| [[Martin St. Louis]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Vermont Catamounts men's ice hockey|Vermont]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Charles Thuss]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Miami RedHawks men's ice hockey|Miami]]
|- 
| [[Kelly Perreault]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]]
|- 
| [[Brian Rafalski]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|-
| [[Brian Holzinger]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]]
|-
| [[Brendan Morrison]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Brian Bonin]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{{col-end}}
{{col-start}}

{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1995–96 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1995–96]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Tim Thomas (ice hockey)|Tim Thomas]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Vermont Catamounts men's ice hockey|Vermont]]
|- 
| [[Jeff Tory]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|- 
| [[Dan McGillis]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Northeastern Huskies men's ice hockey|Northeastern]]
|- 
| [[Jay Pandolfo]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Éric Perrin]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Vermont Catamounts men's ice hockey|Vermont]]
|- 
| [[Martin St. Louis]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Vermont Catamounts men's ice hockey|Vermont]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Ryan Bach]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Keith Aldridge]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Lake Superior State Lakers men's ice hockey|Lake Superior State]]
|- 
| [[Mike Crowley]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|-
| [[Peter Geronozzo]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Brendan Morrison]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Brian Bonin]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1996–97 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1996–97]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Trevor Koenig]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Union Skating Dutchmen men's ice hockey|Union]]
|- 
| [[Jon Coleman]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Matt Pagnutti]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Chris Drury]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Todd White]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Martin St. Louis]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Vermont Catamounts men's ice hockey|Vermont]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Marty Turco]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Dan Boyle (ice hockey)|Dan Boyle]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Miami RedHawks men's ice hockey|Miami]]
|- 
| [[Mike Crowley]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|- 
| [[Randy Robitaille]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Miami RedHawks men's ice hockey|Miami]]
|-
| [[Brendan Morrison]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[John Madden (ice hockey)|John Madden]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1997–98 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1997–98]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Marc Robitaille]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Northeastern Huskies men's ice hockey|Northeastern]]
|- 
| [[Ray Giroux]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Yale Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Yale]]
|- 
| [[Tom Poti]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Chris Drury]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Mark Mowers]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|- 
| [[Marty Reasoner]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Chad Alban]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Dan Boyle (ice hockey)|Dan Boyle]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Miami RedHawks men's ice hockey|Miami]]
|- 
| [[Curtis Murphy]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[Hugo Boisvert]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Ohio State Buckeyes men's ice hockey|Ohio State]]
|- 
| [[Bill Muckalt]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Mike York]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1998–99 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1998–99]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Eric Heffler]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[David Cullen (ice hockey)|David Cullen]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|- 
| [[Mike Mottau]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
| [[Brian Gionta]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
| [[Steve Kariya]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|- 
| [[Jason Krog]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Joe Blackburn]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Scott Swanson]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Brad Williamson (ice hockey)|Brad Williamson]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Jason Blake (ice hockey)|Jason Blake]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[Brian Swanson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|-
| [[Mike York]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[1999–2000 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|1999–00]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Joel Laing]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|- 
| [[Justin Harney]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[Mike Mottau]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
| [[Brian Gionta]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
| [[Andy McDonald (ice hockey)|Andy McDonald]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colgate Red Raiders men's ice hockey|Colgate]]
|- 
| [[Jeff Farkas]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Karl Goehring]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Jeff Dessner]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Jeff Jillson]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Shawn Horcoff]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Jeff Panzer (ice hockey)|Jeff Panzer]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[Steven Reinprecht]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|}
{{col-end}}

====2000s====
{{col-start}}

{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[2000–01 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|2000–01]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Ty Conklin]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|- 
| [[Bobby Allen]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Kent Huskins]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]]
|- 
| [[Erik Anderson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|-
| [[Brian Gionta]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
| [[Jeff Hamilton (ice hockey)|Jeff Hamilton]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Yale Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Yale]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Ryan Miller]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Jordan Leopold]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|- 
| [[Travis Roche]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Dany Heatley]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|-
| [[Andy Hilbert]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Jeff Panzer (ice hockey)|Jeff Panzer]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[2001–02 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|2001–02]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Matt Underhill]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Jim Fahey]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Northeastern Huskies men's ice hockey|Northeastern]]
|- 
| [[Douglas Murray (ice hockey)|Douglas Murray]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Marc Cavosie]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|-
| [[Darren Haydar]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|- 
| [[Colin Hemingway]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Ryan Miller]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Mike Komisarek]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Jordan Leopold]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|-
| [[Mike Cammalleri]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|- 
| [[Mark Hartigan]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[St. Cloud State Huskies men's ice hockey|St. Cloud State]]
|- 
| [[John Pohl]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[2002–03 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|2002–03]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[David LeNeveu]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Freddy Meyer]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Douglas Murray (ice hockey)|Douglas Murray]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Ben Eaves]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
| [[Chris Higgins (ice hockey b. 1983)|Chris Higgins]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Yale Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Yale]]
|-
| [[Dominic Moore]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Mike Brown (goaltender b. 1981)|Mike Brown]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Ferris State Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Ferris State]]
|- 
| [[John-Michael Liles]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Tom Preissing]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|-
| [[Noah Clarke]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Chris Kunitz]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Ferris State Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Ferris State]]
|-
| [[Peter Sejna]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[2003–04 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|2003–04]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Yann Danis]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Brown Bears men's ice hockey|Brown]]
|- 
| [[Andrew Alberts]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Thomas Pöck]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[UMass Minutemen men's ice hockey|Massachusetts]]
|- 
| [[Steve Saviano]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|- 
| [[Lee Stempniak]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Dartmouth Big Green men's ice hockey|Dartmouth]]
|-
| [[Tony Voce]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Bernd Brückler]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Keith Ballard]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|- 
| [[Ryan Caldwell (ice hockey)|Ryan Caldwell]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|- 
| [[Brandon Bochenski]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[Junior Lessard]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|-
| [[Zach Parise]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[2004–05 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|2004–05]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[David McKee (ice hockey)|David McKee]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Andrew Alberts]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Noah Welch]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Sean Collins (ice hockey forward, born 1983)|Sean Collins]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|- 
| [[Patrick Eaves]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Jason Guerriero]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Northeastern Huskies men's ice hockey|Northeastern]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Curtis McElhinney]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Matt Carle]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|- 
| [[Mark Stuart (ice hockey)|Mark Stuart]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|-
| [[T. J. Hensick]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Marty Sertich]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Brett Sterling]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{{col-end}}
{{col-start}}

{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[2005–06 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|2005–06]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Cory Schneider]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Peter Harrold]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Dan Spang]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Chris Collins (ice hockey)|Chris Collins]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Greg Moore (ice hockey)|Greg Moore]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|- 
| [[T. J. Trevelyan]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Brian Elliott]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Matt Carle]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|- 
| [[Andy Greene]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Miami RedHawks men's ice hockey|Miami]]
|-
| [[Scott Parse]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Nebraska-Omaha Mavericks men's ice hockey|Nebraska-Omaha]]
|-
| [[Ryan Potulny]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|- 
| [[Brett Sterling]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[2006–07 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|2006–07]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[John Curry (ice hockey)|John Curry]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Drew Bagnall]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[Reid Cashman]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Quinnipiac Bobcats men's ice hockey|Quinnipiac]]
|- 
| [[Brian Boyle]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[David Jones (ice hockey)|David Jones]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Dartmouth Big Green men's ice hockey|Dartmouth]]
|-
| [[Michel Léveillé]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[David Brown (ice hockey)|David Brown]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Notre Dame Fighting Irish men's ice hockey|Notre Dame]]
|- 
| [[Alex Goligoski]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|- 
| [[Jack Johnson (ice hockey)|Jack Johnson]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Ryan Duncan]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[T. J. Hensick]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Jonathan Toews]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[2007–08 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|2007–08]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Kevin Regan]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|- 
| [[Matt Gilroy]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Mike Moore (ice hockey)|Mike Moore]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Princeton Tigers men's ice hockey|Princeton]]
|-
| [[Nathan Gerbe]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Lee Jubinville]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Princeton Tigers men's ice hockey|Princeton]]
|-
| [[Mike Radja]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Richard Bachman (ice hockey)|Richard Bachman]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|- 
| [[Tyler Eckford]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Alaska Nanooks men's ice hockey|Alaska]]
|- 
| [[Jack Hillen]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|-
| [[Ryan Jones (ice hockey)|Ryan Jones]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Miami RedHawks men's ice hockey|Miami]]
|- 
| [[T. J. Oshie]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[Kevin Porter (ice hockey)|Kevin Porter]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[2008–09 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|2008–09]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Brad Thiessen]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Northeastern Huskies men's ice hockey|Northeastern]]
|- 
| [[Matt Gilroy]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Zach Miskovic]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|-
| [[David McIntyre]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colgate Raiders men's ice hockey|Colgate]]
|- 
| [[Viktor Stålberg]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Vermont Catamounts men's ice hockey|Vermont]]
|-
| [[Colin Wilson (ice hockey)|Colin Wilson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Alex Stalock]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|- 
| [[Ian Cole]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Notre Dame Fighting Irish men's ice hockey|Notre Dame]]
|- 
| [[Jamie McBain]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Louie Caporusso]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Aaron Palushaj]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Ryan Stoa]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[2009–10 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|2009–10]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Ben Scrivens]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|- 
| [[Colby Cohen]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]]
|- 
| [[Brendon Nash]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]]
|-
| [[Bobby Butler (ice hockey)|Bobby Butler]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|-
| [[Gustav Nyquist]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|-
| [[Chase Polacek]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Marc Cheverie]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|- 
| [[Brendan Smith (ice hockey)|Brendan Smith]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Patrick Wiercioch]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|-
| [[Blake Geoffrion]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Mark Olver]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Northern Michigan Wildcats men's ice hockey|Northern Michigan]]
|-
| [[Rhett Rakhshani]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|}
{{col-end}}

====2010s====
{{col-start}}

{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[2010–11 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|2010–11]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Keith Kinkaid]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Union Dutchmen men's ice hockey|Union]]
|- 
| [[Brian Dumoulin]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Blake Kessel]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|-
| [[Cam Atkinson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|- 
| [[Chase Polacek]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|-
| [[Paul Thompson (ice hockey b. 1988)|Paul Thompson]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Pat Nagle]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Ferris State Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Ferris State]]
|- 
| [[Chay Genoway]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Justin Schultz]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Jack Connolly (ice hockey, born 1989)|Jack Connolly]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|-
| [[Matt Frattin]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|-
| [[Andy Miele]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Miami RedHawks men's ice hockey|Miami]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[2011–12 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|2011–12]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Troy Grosenick]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Union Dutchmen men's ice hockey|Union]]
|- 
| [[Danny Biega]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Brian Dumoulin]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
| [[Spencer Abbott (ice hockey)|Spencer Abbott]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]]
|- 
| [[Alex Killorn]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]]
|- 
| [[Austin Smith (ice hockey)|Austin Smith]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colgate Raiders men's ice hockey|Colgate]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Taylor Nelson]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Ferris State Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Ferris State]]
|- 
| [[Torey Krug]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]]
|- 
| [[Justin Schultz]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|-
| [[Jack Connolly (ice hockey, born 1989)|Jack Connolly]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]]
|- 
| [[Jaden Schwartz]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]]
|-
| [[Reilly Smith]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Miami RedHawks men's ice hockey|Miami]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[2012–13 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|2012–13]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Eric Hartzell]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Quinnipiac Bobcats men's ice hockey|Quinnipiac]]
|- 
| [[Nick Bailen]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]]
|- 
| [[Chad Ruhwedel]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[UMass-Lowell River Hawks men's ice hockey|Massachusetts-Lowell]]
|-
| [[Trevor van Riemsdyk]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]]
|-
| [[Kyle Flanagan]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[Johnny Gaudreau]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
| [[Steven Whitney]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Brady Hjelle]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Ohio State Buckeyes men's ice hockey|Ohio State]]
|- 
| [[Nick Jensen]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[St. Cloud State Huskies men's ice hockey|St. Cloud State]]
|- 
| [[Jacob Trouba]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]]
|-
| [[Austin Czarnik]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Miami RedHawks men's ice hockey|Miami]]
|-
| [[Danny Kristo]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[University of North Dakota men's ice hockey|North Dakota]]
|- 
| [[Drew LeBlanc]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[St. Cloud State Huskies men's ice hockey|St. Cloud State]]
|}
{{col-5}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! colspan=3|[[2013–14 NCAA Division I men's ice hockey season|2013–14]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''East'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Connor Hellebuyck]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[UMass–Lowell Riverhawks men's ice hockey|Massachusetts-Lowell]]
|- 
| [[Mathew Bodie]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Union Dutchmen men's ice hockey|Union]]
|- 
| [[Shayne Gostisbehere]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Union Dutchmen men's ice hockey|Union]]
|-
| [[Greg Carey (ice hockey)|Greg Carey]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]]
|- 
| [[Johnny Gaudreau]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
| [[Kevin Hayes (ice hockey)|Kevin Hayes]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]]
|-
! colspan=3|'''West'''
|-
! Player !! Position !! Team
|-
| [[Sam Brittain]] || [[Goaltender]] || [[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]]
|- 
| [[Jake McCabe]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]]
|- 
| [[Mike Reilly (ice hockey)|Mike Reilly]] || [[Defenseman]] || [[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]]
|-
| [[Josh Archibald (ice hockey)|Josh Archibald]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Nebraska-Omaha Mavericks men's ice hockey|Nebraska-Omaha]]
|- 
| [[Nic Dowd]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[St. Cloud State Huskies men's ice hockey|St. Cloud State]]
|-
| [[Ryan Dzingel]] || [[Forward (ice hockey)|Forward]] || [[Ohio State Buckeyes men's ice hockey|Ohio State]]
|}
{{col-end}}
{{col-start}}

{{col-2}}

====First Team players by school====
{{col-start}}
{{col-2}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! style="background:#e5e5e5;"| School !! style="background:#e5e5e5;"| Winners
|-
|[[North Dakota Fighting Sioux men's ice hockey|North Dakota]] || 49
|-
|[[Boston College Eagles men's ice hockey|Boston College]] || 48
|-
|[[Boston University Terriers men's ice hockey|Boston University]] || 48
|-
|[[Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey|Michigan]] || 45
|-
|[[Colorado College Tigers men's ice hockey|Colorado College]] || 37
|-
|[[Michigan State Spartans men's ice hockey|Michigan State]] || 36
|-
|[[Minnesota Golden Gophers men's ice hockey|Minnesota]] || 34
|-
|[[Clarkson Golden Knights men's ice hockey|Clarkson]] || 33
|-
|[[Cornell Big Red men's ice hockey|Cornell]] || 33
|-
|[[Denver Pioneers men's ice hockey|Denver]] || 33
|-
|[[Wisconsin Badgers men's ice hockey|Wisconsin]] || 32
|-
|[[Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey|Harvard]] || 29
|-
|[[Michigan Tech Huskies men's ice hockey|Michigan Tech]] || 28
|-
|[[Minnesota-Duluth Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Minnesota-Duluth]] || 24
|-
|[[New Hampshire Wildcats men's ice hockey|New Hampshire]] || 24
|-
|[[St. Lawrence Saints men's ice hockey|St. Lawrence]] || 24
|-
|[[Maine Black Bears men's ice hockey|Maine]] || 21
|-
|[[RPI Engineers men's ice hockey|Rensselaer]] || 18
|-
|[[Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey|Bowling Green]] || 15
|-
|[[Vermont Catamounts men's ice hockey|Vermont]] || 12
|-
|[[Northeastern Huskies men's ice hockey|Northeastern]] || 11
|}
{{col-2}}
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! style="background:#e5e5e5;"| School !! style="background:#e5e5e5;"| Winners
|-
|[[Brown Bears men's ice hockey|Brown]] || 9
|-
|[[Miami RedHawks men's ice hockey|Miami]] || 9
|-
|[[Notre Dame Fighting Irish men's ice hockey|Notre Dame]] || 9
|-
|[[Colgate Raiders men's ice hockey|Colgate]] || 8
|-
|[[Lake Superior State Lakers men's ice hockey|Lake Superior State]] || 8
|-
|[[Providence Friars men's ice hockey|Providence]] || 8
|-
|[[Yale Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Yale]] || 8
|-
|[[Dartmouth Big Green men's ice hockey|Dartmouth]] || 5
|-
|[[Ferris State Bulldogs men's ice hockey|Ferris State]] || 5
|-
|[[Middlebury Panthers|Middlebury]] || 5
|-
|[[Northern Michigan Wildcats men's ice hockey|Northern Michigan]] || 5
|-
|[[Union Dutchmen men's ice hockey|Union]] || 5
|-
|[[UMass-Lowell River Hawks men's ice hockey|Massachusetts-Lowell]] || 4
|-
|[[Ohio State Buckeyes men's ice hockey|Ohio State]] || 4
|-
|[[St. Cloud State Huskies men's ice hockey|St. Cloud State]] || 3
|-
|[[Princeton Tigers men's ice hockey|Princeton]] || 3
|-
|[[Western Michigan Broncos men's ice hockey|Western Michigan]] || 3
|-
|[[Colby Mules|Colby]] || 2
|-
|[[Nebraska-Omaha Mavericks men's ice hockey|Nebraska-Omaha]] || 2
|-
|[[Quinnipiac Bobcats men's ice hockey|Quinnipiac]] || 2
|-
|[[Alaska Nanooks men's ice hockey|Alaska]] || 1
|-
|[[UMass Minutemen ice hockey|Massachusetts]] || 1
|}
{{col-end}}

{{col-2}}

====Multiple appearances====
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! style="background:#e5e5e5;"| Player !! style="background:#e5e5e5;"| First Team appearances 
|-
| [[Joe Cavanagh]] || 3
|-
| [[Ken Dryden]] || 3
|-
| [[Mike Eaves]] || 3
|-
| [[Tony Esposito]] || 3
|-
| [[Mark Fusco]] || 3
|-
| [[Brian Gionta]] || 3
|-
| [[Phil Latreille]] || 3
|-
| [[Bill MacFarland]] || 3
|-
| [[Rick Meagher]] || 3
|-
| [[Brendan Morrison]] || 3
|-
| [[Martin St. Louis]] || 3
|-
| many player tied with || 2
|}
{{col-end}}