First Team All-Americans[]
- F Doug Ferguson, 1966, 1967
- G Ken Dryden, 1967, 1968, 1969
- D Harry Orr, 1967
- F Brian Cornell, 1968, 1969
- D Bruce Pattison, 1968, 1969
- D Walt Stanowski, 1968
- F Pete Tufford, 1969
- D Dan Lodboa, 1970
- F Kevin Pettit, 1971
- F Larry Fullan, 1972
- F George Kuzmicz, 1974
- F Lance Nethery, 1978, 1979
- D Pete Shier, 1978
- G Brian Hayward, 1982
- G Darren Eliot, 1983
- G Doug Dadswell, 1986
- F Joe Nieuwendyk, 1986, 1987
- D Dan Ratushny, 1991
- G Parris Duffus, 1992
- D Doug Murray, 2002, 2003
- G Matt Underhill, 2002
- G David LeNeveu, 2003
- G David McKee, 2005
Second Team All-Americans[]
ECAC Player of the Year[]
- F Doug Ferguson, 1967
- G Ken Dryden, 1969
- F Lance Nethery, 1978
- F Joe Nieuwendyk, 1987
- G David LeNeveu, 2003
- G David McKee, 2005
All-ECAC First Team[]
- F Doug Ferguson, 1966, 1967
- D Harry Orr, 1967
- G Ken Dryden, 1967, 1968, 1969
- F Pete Tufford, 1968
- D Bruce Pattison, 1968, 1969
- D Walt Stanowski, 1968
- F Brian Cornell, 1969
- D Dan Lodboa, 1970
- G Brian Cropper, 1970
- F Larry Fullan, 1972
- F Carlo Ugolini, 1973
- F George Kuzmicz, 1974
- F Lance Nethery, 1978, 1979
- D Pete Shier, 1978
- G Brian Hayward, 1982
- G Darren Eliot, 1983
- F Joe Nieuwendyk, 1986, 1987
- D Dan Ratushny, 1990, 1991
- D Steve Wilson, 1996
- D Chad Wilson, 1997
- D Jeff Burgoyne, 1999
- D Doug Murray, 2002, 2003
- G Matt Underhill, 2002
- G David LeNeveu, 2003
- F Matt Moulson, 2005
- G David McKee, 2005
Ken Dryden Award[]
- G Matt Underhill, 2002
- G David LeNeveu, 2003
- G David McKee, 2005
ECAC Rookie of the Year[]
- F Doug Ferguson, 1965
- F Joe Nieuwendyk, 1985
- F Trent Andison, 1988
- F Kent Manderville, 1990
- F Kyle Knopp, 1996
Most Outstanding Player of the NCAA Tournament[]
- D Walt Stanowski, 1967
- D Dan Lodboa, 1970
Most Outstanding Player of the ECAC Tournament[]
- F Doug Ferguson, 1967
- G Ken Dryden, 1968, 1969
- F Carlo Ugolini, 1973
- G Darren Eliot, 1980
- G Doug Dadswell, 1986
- G Jason Elliott, 1996, 1997
- G David LeNeveu, 2003
- D Charlie Cook, 2005
Ivy League Player of the Year[]
- F Brock Tredway, 1981
- F Duane Moeser, 1984
- F Joe Nieuwendyk, 1987
- F Brad Chartrand, 1996
- F Kyle Knopp, 1997
- D Doug Murray, 2002
- G David LeNeveu, 2003
- G David McKee, 2005
All-Ivy First Team[]
- G Laing Kennedy, 1962, 1963
- D George Walker, 1964
- F Doug Ferguson, 1965, 1966
- G Errol McKibbon, 1965, 1966
- F Mike Doran, 1966
- D Harry Orr, 1966, 1967
- G Ken Dryden, 1967, 1968, 1969
- D Walt Stanowski, 1967, 1968
- F Brian Cornell, 1968, 1969
- D Bruce Pattison, 1968, 1969
- F Pete Tufford, 1968, 1969
- F John Hughes, 1970
- D Dan Lodboa, 1970
- F Kevin Pettit, 1970
- G Brian Cropper, 1971
- D Jim Higgs, 1971, 1972
- F Brian McCutcheon, 1971
- F Larry Fullan, 1972
- D Roy Simpson, 1972
- G Dave Elenbaas, 1973
- D Bill Murray, 1973
- F Carlo Ugolini, 1973
- F George Kuzmicz, 1974
- D Steve Bajinski, 1975
- F Dave Peace, 1975
- F Lance Nethery, 1977, 1978, 1979
- F Roy Kerling, 1978, 1980
- D Pete Shier, 1978
- F Brock Tredway, 1979, 1980, 1981
- D Rob Gemmell, 1979
- D Geoff Roeszler, 1980, 1981
- F Jeff Baikie, 1981
- G Darren Elliott, 1981, 1983
- G Brian Hayward, 1982
- D Joe Gallant, 1982
- F Geoff Dervin, 1984
- F Duane Moeser, 1984, 1985
- F Joe Nieuwendyk, 1986, 1987
- F Trent Andison, 1988
- G Corrie D'Alessio, 1988, 1991
- D Chris Norton, 1988
- D Dan Ratushny, 1990, 1991
- G Parris Duffus, 1992
- D Steve Wilson, 1995, 1996, 1997
- F Brad Chartrand, 1996
- G Eddy Skazyk, 1996
- F Vinnie Auger, 1997
- G Jason Eliot, 1997
- F Kyle Knopp, 1997
- D Chad Wilson, 1997
- D Jeff Burgoyne, 1999
- D Doug Murray, 2001, 2002, 2003
- G Matt Underhill, 2001, 2002
- G David LeNeveu, 2003
- F Ryan Vesce, 2003, 2004
- F Matt Moulson, 2004, 2005
- G David McKee, 2005
- D Charlie Cook, 2005
Ivy League Rookie of the Year[]
- F Joe Nieuwendyk, 1985
- G Corrie D'Alessio, 1988
- F Vinnie Auger, 1994
- F Kyle Knopp, 1996
- F Denis Ladouceur, 1999
