The Jinelle Siergiej Award was introduced in 2011. The criteria for the award is the "Overall Offensive Player of the Year". The award is presented to a female ice hockey player from Wisconsin prep school and coaches are asked to nominate a player from their respective team.
Winners[]
| Year | Winner | Team |
| 2011 | Alice Cranston [1] | St. Croix Valley Fusion |
| 2012 | Theresa Knutson | Onalaska Hilltoppers |
| 2013 | Theresa Knutson | Onalaska Hilltoppers |
| 2014 | Theresa Knutson | Onalaska Hilltoppers |
| 2015 | Nicole Unsworth | University School of Milwaukee Wildcats |
| 2016 | Nicole Unsworth | University School of Milwaukee Wildcats |