The Jessie Vetter Award was introduced in 2010. It is awarded to the top female ice hockey goaltender in Wisconsin prep school.
Winners[]
| Year | Winner | Team |
| 2010 | Hillary Drake | Central Wisconsin Storm |
| 2011 | Hillary Drake[1] | Central Wisconsin Storm |
| 2012 | Julia Brueggen | Viroqua Blackhawks |
| 2013 | Mackenzie Torpy | Stoughton Icebergs |
| 2014 | Mackenzie Torpy | Stoughton Icebergs |
| 2015 | Mackenzie Torpy | Stoughton Icebergs |
| 2016 | Erin Connolly | Lakeshore Lightning |