The Titans finished the 2003-04 regular season in second place behind the Mohawk Valley Comets. In the playoffs, Jamestown played the York IceCats a 2 game series for the league Championship. If there were a tie after the 2 games they would play a 20-minute mini game. York won the opening game, 8-5. Jamestown defeated York 9-1 in the second game and then won a 20-minute tiebreaker game 6-1. As league champions, the Titans received the Herb Brooks Memorial Trophy.