This is a list of the Eastern Professional Hockey League All-Star teams during the league's existence from 1959-60 to 1962-63.
1959-60[]
First All-Star Team[]
- Goaltender: Gerry McNeil,, Montreal Royals
- Defenceman: J.C. Tremblay, Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
- Defenceman: Moe Mantha, Montreal Royals
- Left Winger: Tom McCarthy, Sudbury Wolves
- Right Winger: Bob Courcy, Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
- Centre: Cal Gardner, Kingston Frontenacs
Second All-Star Team[]
- Goaltender: Claude Evans, Trois Rivieres Lions
- Defenceman: Garry Blaine, Sault Ste. Marie Thunderbirds
- Defenceman: Gerry Odrowski, Sudbury Wolves
- Left Winger: Gilles Tremblay, Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
- Right Winger: Orval Tessier, Kingston Frontenacs
- Centre: Bill Carter, Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
1960-61[]
First All-Star Team[]
- Goaltender: Ed Johnston, Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
- Defenceman: Jean Gauthier, Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
- Defenceman: Al MacNeil, Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
- Left Winger: Fred Hilts, Sault Ste, Marie Thunderbirds
- Right Winger: Bobby Rousseau, Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
- Centre: Cliff Pennington, Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
Second All-Star Team[]
- Goaltender: Gerry McNamara, Sudbury Wolves
- Defenceman: Pat Stapleton, Sault Ste. Marie Thunderbirds
- Defenceman: Jack Bownass, Kitchener-Waterloo Beavers
- Left Winger: Silvio Bettio. Sudbury Wolves
- Right Winger: Eddie Kachur. Sault Ste. Marie Thunderbirds
- Centre: Skippy Burchell. Montreal Royals
Hull-Ottawa members of the All-Star team. From left: Jean Gauthier, Al MacNeil. Eddie Johnston, Cliff Pennington, & Bobby Rousseau.
1961-62[]
First All-Star Team[]
- Goaltender: Cesare Maniago, Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
- Defenceman: Harry Sinden, Kingston Frontenacs
- Defenceman: Jean Gauthier, Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
- Left Winger: Tom McCarthy, Kingston Frontenacs
- Right Winger: Keith McCreary. Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
- Centre: Orval Tessier, Kingston Frontenacs
Second All-Star Team[]
- Goaltender: Jack McCartan, Kitchener-Waterloo Beavers
- Defenceman: Jack Bownass, Kitchener-Waterloo Beavers
- Defenceman: Jim Neilson, Kitchener-Waterloo Beavers
- Left Winger: Len Ronson, Kitchener-Waterloo Beavers
- Right Winger: Leon Rochefort, Kitchener-Waterloo Beavers
- Centre: Bob Attersley, Kingston Frontenacs
1962-63[]
First All-Star Team[]
- Goaltender: Bruce Gamble, Kingston Frontenacs
- Defenceman: Harry Sinden, Kingston Frontenacs
- Defenceman: Pat Stapleton, Kingston Frontenacs
- Left Winger: Jeannot Gilbert, Kingston Frontenacs
- Right Winger: Alain Caron, St. Louis Braves
- Centre: Don Blackburn, Kingston Frontenacs
Second All-Star Team[]
- Goaltender: Ernie Wakely, Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
- Defenceman: Jacques Laperriere, Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
- Defenceman: Terry Harper, Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
- Left Winger: Marc Dufour, Sudbury Wolves
- Right Winger: Keith McCreary, Hull-Ottawa Canadiens
- Centre: Murray Hall, St. Louis Braves