1939-40 Newfoundland Senior Season

First Round
Sudden death


 * Bay Roberts 5 Conception Bay Cupids 1

Quarter Final
Sudden death


 * Bell Island 12 Bay Roberts 1

Semi Final
2 games total goals

Buchans beat Grand Falls 11 goals to 8.


 * St. Bonaventure's 4 Bell Island 2
 * St. Bonaventure's 2 Bell Island 1

St. Bonaventure's beat Bell Island 6 goals to 3.

Final
2 games total goals


 * St. Bonaventure's 12 Buchans 1
 * Buchans 6 St. Bonaventure's 3

St. Bonaventure's beat Buchans 11 goals to 7.

St. Bonaventure's won the Herder Memorial Trophy.